MA.1.AR.1.2

Solve addition and subtraction real-world problems using objects, drawings or equations to represent the problem.

Clarifications

Clarification 1: Instruction includes understanding the context of the problem, as well as the quantities within the problem. 
Clarification 2: Students are not expected to independently read word problems. 
Clarification 3: Addition and subtraction are limited to sums within 20 and related subtraction facts. Refer to Situations Involving Operations with Numbers (Appendix A).
General Information
Subject Area: Mathematics (B.E.S.T.)
Grade: 1
Strand: Algebraic Reasoning
Status: State Board Approved

Benchmark Instructional Guide

Connecting Benchmarks/Horizontal Alignment

 

Terms from the K-12 Glossary

  • NA

 

Vertical Alignment

Previous Benchmarks

 

Next Benchmarks

 

 

Purpose and Instructional Strategies

The purpose of this benchmark is for students to start to apply their understanding of mathematical concepts as they critically apply their knowledge in visualizing and deciphering word problems. In Kindergarten, students solved real-world addition and subtraction problems within 10, with a focus on drawings and equations to represent problems. Students are not expected to independently read word problems (MTR.7.1). 
  • Instruction allows students to focus on context and apply reasoning to determine the appropriate operation (MTR.7.1). 
  • Instruction includes helping students realize that there can be more than one representation for a given problem which could be helpful for students to choose which representation they prefer and to communicate with other students who might prefer a different representation (MTR.2.1, MTR.4.1, MTR.5.1). 
  • Instruction includes getting students to assess the reasonableness of their solutions within context (MTR.6.1). 
  • Instruction may begin with concrete models, pictures, numbers and words, and then move into writing equations (MTR.2.1). 
  • Instruction should include a variety of problem types (see Appendix A) and not a focus on any single problem type. It is important that students have opportunities to solve various problem types.

 

Common Misconceptions or Errors

  • Students may have difficulty modeling or solving problems that involve a change unknown or start unknown problem type. To help with this misconception, include the use of Appendix A in instruction. 
  • Students may look for key words rather than context and reasoning, which can lead to the wrong operation.

 

Strategies to Support Tiered Instruction

  • Instruction provides the opportunity to create word problems to match change unknown and start unknown problem types. 
    • For example, the teacher provides the change unknown equation 12 − ____ = 8 to the students. Students develop a situation that matches the equation to make into a word problem. 
  • Instruction provides the opportunity to determine the context of word problems with a focus on what is happening in the problem and how it can be solved. 
    • For example, the teacher provides the following word problem: Patrick’s Pet Care washed 3 dogs in the morning and some more dogs in the afternoon. Patrick washed a total of 7 dogs. How many dogs did Patrick wash in the afternoon? Teacher asks “What is this problem about? What is happening in this problem? What information do we know? How do you think you would solve this problem?” 
  • Teacher provides a variety of change unknown and start unknown problems for students to match to the correct equation. Problem types and examples can be found in Appendix A. 

a variety of change unknown and start unknown problems

  • Teacher provides a graphic organizer to identify important information for solving the problem. 
    • For example, students develop an understanding of context and reasoning by answering questions about the context and gathering information from the problem to promote reasoning.

 

Instructional Tasks

Instructional Task 1 (MTR.4.1

There are chickens, sheep and pigs in a barn. There are 17 animals total in the barn. 
  • Part A. How many chickens, sheep and pigs could be in the barn? 
  • Part B. With a partner, compare your work. How are your barns alike? How are your barns different? 

 

Instructional Task 2 (MTR.1.1, MTR.2.1, MTR.7.1

Provide students with the equation 12= __+7. Provide time for students to draw a picture that represents the equation then verbally express a word problem to match.

 

Instructional Items

Instructional Item 1 

Trevor had 16 toy cars. He went to the toy store with his father. His father bought him some more toy cars. When Trevor got home, he counted his cars and now he has 20 cars. How many toy cars did his father buy for him? Write an equation to show how you solved the problem. 

 

Instructional Item 2 

Elliana had 19 stuffed animals. She gave some away. Now Elliana has 11 stuffed animals. How many stuffed animals did Elliana give away? Draw a picture to show your work. 

 

*The strategies, tasks and items included in the B1G-M are examples and should not be considered comprehensive.

Related Courses

This benchmark is part of these courses.
5012030: Grade One Mathematics (Specifically in versions: 2014 - 2015, 2015 - 2022, 2022 - 2024, 2024 and beyond (current))
7712020: Access Mathematics Grade 1 (Specifically in versions: 2014 - 2015, 2015 - 2018, 2018 - 2022, 2022 and beyond (current))
5012005: Foundational Skills in Mathematics K-2 (Specifically in versions: 2019 - 2022, 2022 - 2024, 2024 and beyond (current))

Related Access Points

Alternate version of this benchmark for students with significant cognitive disabilities.
MA.1.AR.1.AP.2: Solve addition and subtraction real-world problems within 10 using objects, drawings or equations to represent the problem.

Related Resources

Vetted resources educators can use to teach the concepts and skills in this benchmark.

Formative Assessments

Turtles in a Pond:

Students are given pairs of word problems that can be solved using the Commutative Property of addition.

Type: Formative Assessment

Take From (Result Unknown):

Students are asked to solve two Take From (Result Unknown) word problems using pencil and paper or other appropriate manipulatives.

Type: Formative Assessment

Add To (Change Unknown) Word Problems:

Students are asked to solve two Add To (Change Unknown) word problems using pencil and paper or other appropriate manipulatives.

Type: Formative Assessment

Take From (Start Unknown):

Students are asked to solve two Take From (Start Unknown) word problems using pencil and paper or other appropriate manipulatives.

Type: Formative Assessment

Compare (Smaller Unknown) Word Problems:

Students are asked to solve two Compare (Smaller Unknown) word problems using pencil and paper or other appropriate manipulatives.

Type: Formative Assessment

How Many M&M's?:

Students are asked to solve two Compare problems presented using the terms more than and fewer than.

Type: Formative Assessment

How Many More Stickers?:

Students are asked to solve a Compare (Difference Unknown) word problem using pencil and paper or other appropriate manipulatives.

Type: Formative Assessment

Compare (Difference Unknown) Word Problems:

Students are asked to solve two Compare (Difference Unknown) word problems within 20 using pencil and paper or other appropriate manipulatives.

Type: Formative Assessment

Compare (Bigger Unknown) Word Problems:

Students are asked to solve two Compare (Bigger Unknown) problems presented using the terms more than and fewer than.

Type: Formative Assessment

Both Addends Unknown:

Students are asked to solve a Put Together/Take Apart (Both Addends Unknown) word problem and explain their strategies.

Type: Formative Assessment

Trains and Jump Ropes:

Students are asked to solve two Compare problems presented using the terms more than and fewer than.

Type: Formative Assessment

The Cupcake Problem:

Students are asked to solve two Take From (Start Unknown) word problems using pencil and paper or other appropriate manipulatives.

Type: Formative Assessment

Take From (Change Unknown) Word Problems:

Students are asked to solve two Take From (Change Unknown) word problems using pencil and paper or other appropriate manipulatives.

Type: Formative Assessment

Red Birds and Blue Birds:

Students are asked to solve two Put Together/Take Apart (Addend Unknown) word problems using pencil and paper or other appropriate manipulatives.

Type: Formative Assessment

Put Together/Take Apart (Total Unknown):

Students are asked to solve two Put Together/Take Apart (Total Unknown) word problems using pencil and paper or other appropriate manipulatives.

Type: Formative Assessment

Put Together/Take Apart (Both Addends Unknown) Word Problems:

Students are asked to solve a Put Together/Take Apart (Both Addends Unknown) word problem using pencil and paper or other appropriate manipulatives.

Type: Formative Assessment

Put Together/Take Apart (Addend Unknown) Word Problem:

Students are asked to solve two Put Together/Take Apart (Addend Unknown) word problems using pencil and paper or other appropriate manipulatives.

Type: Formative Assessment

More Add To (Change Unknown) Problems:

Students are asked to solve two Add To (Change Unknown) word problems using pencil and paper or other appropriate manipulatives.

Type: Formative Assessment

Add To (Start Unknown) Word Problems:

Students are asked to solve two Add To (Start Unknown) word problems using pencil and paper or other appropriate manipulatives.

Type: Formative Assessment

Add To (Result Unknown) Word Problems:

Students are asked to solve two Add To (Result Unknown) word problems using pencil and paper or other appropriate manipulatives.

Type: Formative Assessment

Fish in a Pond:

Students solve a Take From (Start Unknown) word problem.

Type: Formative Assessment

Birds on a Branch:

Students are asked to solve two Take From (Change Unknown) word problems using pencil and paper or other appropriate manipulatives.

Type: Formative Assessment

Lesson Plans

The Whole Part:

Students will participate in a variety of activities and use part-part-whole graphic organizers to discover unknown addends in put together addition situations.

Type: Lesson Plan

Pete's Groovy Button Problems:

This lesson uses a familiar character, Pete the Cat, that proposes a comparison problem for students to explore.

Type: Lesson Plan

Addition Stories at the Food Store:

In this lesson, students will solve addition whole number word problems (within 20) with real-world scenarios by using manipulatives, drawings, or equations.

Type: Lesson Plan

Cookie Subtraction:

In this lesson, the teacher shares the book, "Mmm... Cookie Simple Subtraction". The students follow along by representing the problems in the book with cookie manipulatives and recording the equations for each problem. The lesson incorporates a variety of subtraction problem types.

Type: Lesson Plan

Get Up and Go! with Addition and Subtraction:

The lesson involves students adding and subtracting on a number line while follwoing a story that explains the amount of time taken to get ready in the morning. Students will write addition and subtraction equations to represent the parts of the story.

Type: Lesson Plan

What's Missing?:

In this lesson, students learn to solve addition equations that have a missing addend within 10.

Type: Lesson Plan

Word Problem Lesson:

In this lesson, students will be able to solve "compare" word problems.

Type: Lesson Plan

Solving Word Problems Using Story Structure:

In this lesson, students will learn how to use their knowledge of beginning, middle, and end to solve word problems that include result unknown, change unknown, and start unknown. They will learn how to use a modified story map to write an equation to represent the problem.

Type: Lesson Plan

Dangerous Doubles (Doubling Numbers):

This lesson teaches students to use the strategy doubling numbers and doubles plus or minus one in order to use mental math to add one-digit numbers. The students are engaged in learning through the read-aloud of "Double the Ducks" by Stephen Murphy and then get to work with a partner to draw doubles and write equations that relate to their drawings. Students individually work on solving word problems using these strategies and manipulatives as necessary to solve.

Type: Lesson Plan

Rock Around the Clock:

In this lesson, students will use addition or subtraction strategies to solve a real-world problem about developing a music playlist.

Type: Lesson Plan

Original Student Tutorials

A Birthday Party: Addition:

Join Juliana for her 8th birthday party! Learn to solve addition problems within 20 using objects and creating drawings in this interactive student tutorial. 

Type: Original Student Tutorial

Addition Word Problems Around the Zoo - Part 1:

Help Mario and Gretchen model and write equations for addition word problems, in this interactive tutorial.

This is part 1 in a 3-part series. Click below to explore the other tutorials in the series. 
Part 1: Addition Word Problems Around the Zoo (this one)
Part 2: Subtraction Word Problems Around the Zoo
Part 3: Word Problems Around the Zoo

Type: Original Student Tutorial

Subtraction Word Problems Around the Zoo - Part 2:

Help Mario and Gretchen model and write equations for subtraction word problems in this interactive tutorial.

This is part 2 in a 3-part series. Click below to explore the other tutorials in the series. 

Part 1: Addition Word Problems Around the Zoo

Part 2: Subtraction Word Problems Around the Zoo (this one)

Part 3: Word Problems Around the Zoo

Type: Original Student Tutorial

Word Problems Around the Zoo - Part 3:

Help Gretchen and Mario differentiate between addition and subtraction word problems during their field trip to the zoo in this interactive tutorial.

This is part 3 in a 3-part series. Click below to explore the other tutorials in the series. 
Part 1: Addition Word Problems Around the Zoo
Part 2: Subtraction Word Problems Around the Zoo
Part 3: Word Problems Around the Zoo (this one)

Type: Original Student Tutorial

Problem-Solving Tasks

Finding a Chair:

These problems explicitly describe one-to-one correspondences without using comparison language. Such problems are easier for students to solve than problems that use comparison language such as "How many more?" or "How many fewer."

Type: Problem-Solving Task

Field Day Scarcity:

The purpose of this task is for students to relate addition and subtraction problems to money in a context that introduces the concept of scarcity. Scarcity occurs when you want or need more than you can have. Students may want to buy everything but will discover that it not possible with only $7 and they will have to make decisions.

Type: Problem-Solving Task

Boys and Girls, Variation 1:

Students may use either addition or subtraction to solve these types of word problems, with addition related to the action of putting together and subtraction related to the action of taking apart. Depending on how students think about these word problems, either is appropriate for the "addend unknown" problems. Seeing it both ways emphasizes the relationship between addition and subtraction.

Type: Problem-Solving Task

At the Park:

This task includes three different problem types using the "Add To" context with a discrete quantity.

Type: Problem-Solving Task

Maria’s Marbles:

Students benefit from encountering one problem type limited to small numbers and to develop strategies for that type of problem before encountering mixed sets of problems and larger numbers that distract the student from the problem itself. Over time they will be able to distinguish between types of problems in mixed sets and apply the appropriate strategy to solve each.

Type: Problem-Solving Task

The Pet Snake:

The purpose of this task is for students to gain a better understanding of measurements with the example being the growth of a pet snake.

Type: Problem-Solving Task

Sharing Markers:

These task types represent the Take From contexts for addition and subtraction. This task includes the three different problem types using the Take From context: result unknown, change unknown, and start unknown. Students need experience and practice with all three types.

Type: Problem-Solving Task

Tutorial

Exercising gorillas:

In this tutorial video from Khan Academy, a word problem is solved with unit cubes, as well as with a missing addend addition equation and a subtraction equation.

Type: Tutorial

MFAS Formative Assessments

Add To (Change Unknown) Word Problems:

Students are asked to solve two Add To (Change Unknown) word problems using pencil and paper or other appropriate manipulatives.

Add To (Result Unknown) Word Problems:

Students are asked to solve two Add To (Result Unknown) word problems using pencil and paper or other appropriate manipulatives.

Add To (Start Unknown) Word Problems:

Students are asked to solve two Add To (Start Unknown) word problems using pencil and paper or other appropriate manipulatives.

Birds on a Branch:

Students are asked to solve two Take From (Change Unknown) word problems using pencil and paper or other appropriate manipulatives.

Both Addends Unknown:

Students are asked to solve a Put Together/Take Apart (Both Addends Unknown) word problem and explain their strategies.

Compare (Bigger Unknown) Word Problems:

Students are asked to solve two Compare (Bigger Unknown) problems presented using the terms more than and fewer than.

Compare (Difference Unknown) Word Problems:

Students are asked to solve two Compare (Difference Unknown) word problems within 20 using pencil and paper or other appropriate manipulatives.

Compare (Smaller Unknown) Word Problems:

Students are asked to solve two Compare (Smaller Unknown) word problems using pencil and paper or other appropriate manipulatives.

Fish in a Pond:

Students solve a Take From (Start Unknown) word problem.

How Many M&M's?:

Students are asked to solve two Compare problems presented using the terms more than and fewer than.

How Many More Stickers?:

Students are asked to solve a Compare (Difference Unknown) word problem using pencil and paper or other appropriate manipulatives.

More Add To (Change Unknown) Problems:

Students are asked to solve two Add To (Change Unknown) word problems using pencil and paper or other appropriate manipulatives.

Put Together/Take Apart (Addend Unknown) Word Problem:

Students are asked to solve two Put Together/Take Apart (Addend Unknown) word problems using pencil and paper or other appropriate manipulatives.

Put Together/Take Apart (Both Addends Unknown) Word Problems:

Students are asked to solve a Put Together/Take Apart (Both Addends Unknown) word problem using pencil and paper or other appropriate manipulatives.

Put Together/Take Apart (Total Unknown):

Students are asked to solve two Put Together/Take Apart (Total Unknown) word problems using pencil and paper or other appropriate manipulatives.

Red Birds and Blue Birds:

Students are asked to solve two Put Together/Take Apart (Addend Unknown) word problems using pencil and paper or other appropriate manipulatives.

Take From (Change Unknown) Word Problems:

Students are asked to solve two Take From (Change Unknown) word problems using pencil and paper or other appropriate manipulatives.

Take From (Result Unknown):

Students are asked to solve two Take From (Result Unknown) word problems using pencil and paper or other appropriate manipulatives.

Take From (Start Unknown):

Students are asked to solve two Take From (Start Unknown) word problems using pencil and paper or other appropriate manipulatives.

The Cupcake Problem:

Students are asked to solve two Take From (Start Unknown) word problems using pencil and paper or other appropriate manipulatives.

Trains and Jump Ropes:

Students are asked to solve two Compare problems presented using the terms more than and fewer than.

Turtles in a Pond:

Students are given pairs of word problems that can be solved using the Commutative Property of addition.

Original Student Tutorials Mathematics - Grades K-5

A Birthday Party: Addition:

Join Juliana for her 8th birthday party! Learn to solve addition problems within 20 using objects and creating drawings in this interactive student tutorial. 

Addition Word Problems Around the Zoo - Part 1:

Help Mario and Gretchen model and write equations for addition word problems, in this interactive tutorial.

This is part 1 in a 3-part series. Click below to explore the other tutorials in the series. 
Part 1: Addition Word Problems Around the Zoo (this one)
Part 2: Subtraction Word Problems Around the Zoo
Part 3: Word Problems Around the Zoo

Subtraction Word Problems Around the Zoo - Part 2:

Help Mario and Gretchen model and write equations for subtraction word problems in this interactive tutorial.

This is part 2 in a 3-part series. Click below to explore the other tutorials in the series. 

Part 1: Addition Word Problems Around the Zoo

Part 2: Subtraction Word Problems Around the Zoo (this one)

Part 3: Word Problems Around the Zoo

Word Problems Around the Zoo - Part 3:

Help Gretchen and Mario differentiate between addition and subtraction word problems during their field trip to the zoo in this interactive tutorial.

This is part 3 in a 3-part series. Click below to explore the other tutorials in the series. 
Part 1: Addition Word Problems Around the Zoo
Part 2: Subtraction Word Problems Around the Zoo
Part 3: Word Problems Around the Zoo (this one)

Student Resources

Vetted resources students can use to learn the concepts and skills in this benchmark.

Original Student Tutorials

A Birthday Party: Addition:

Join Juliana for her 8th birthday party! Learn to solve addition problems within 20 using objects and creating drawings in this interactive student tutorial. 

Type: Original Student Tutorial

Addition Word Problems Around the Zoo - Part 1:

Help Mario and Gretchen model and write equations for addition word problems, in this interactive tutorial.

This is part 1 in a 3-part series. Click below to explore the other tutorials in the series. 
Part 1: Addition Word Problems Around the Zoo (this one)
Part 2: Subtraction Word Problems Around the Zoo
Part 3: Word Problems Around the Zoo

Type: Original Student Tutorial

Subtraction Word Problems Around the Zoo - Part 2:

Help Mario and Gretchen model and write equations for subtraction word problems in this interactive tutorial.

This is part 2 in a 3-part series. Click below to explore the other tutorials in the series. 

Part 1: Addition Word Problems Around the Zoo

Part 2: Subtraction Word Problems Around the Zoo (this one)

Part 3: Word Problems Around the Zoo

Type: Original Student Tutorial

Word Problems Around the Zoo - Part 3:

Help Gretchen and Mario differentiate between addition and subtraction word problems during their field trip to the zoo in this interactive tutorial.

This is part 3 in a 3-part series. Click below to explore the other tutorials in the series. 
Part 1: Addition Word Problems Around the Zoo
Part 2: Subtraction Word Problems Around the Zoo
Part 3: Word Problems Around the Zoo (this one)

Type: Original Student Tutorial

Problem-Solving Tasks

Finding a Chair:

These problems explicitly describe one-to-one correspondences without using comparison language. Such problems are easier for students to solve than problems that use comparison language such as "How many more?" or "How many fewer."

Type: Problem-Solving Task

Boys and Girls, Variation 1:

Students may use either addition or subtraction to solve these types of word problems, with addition related to the action of putting together and subtraction related to the action of taking apart. Depending on how students think about these word problems, either is appropriate for the "addend unknown" problems. Seeing it both ways emphasizes the relationship between addition and subtraction.

Type: Problem-Solving Task

At the Park:

This task includes three different problem types using the "Add To" context with a discrete quantity.

Type: Problem-Solving Task

Maria’s Marbles:

Students benefit from encountering one problem type limited to small numbers and to develop strategies for that type of problem before encountering mixed sets of problems and larger numbers that distract the student from the problem itself. Over time they will be able to distinguish between types of problems in mixed sets and apply the appropriate strategy to solve each.

Type: Problem-Solving Task

The Pet Snake:

The purpose of this task is for students to gain a better understanding of measurements with the example being the growth of a pet snake.

Type: Problem-Solving Task

Sharing Markers:

These task types represent the Take From contexts for addition and subtraction. This task includes the three different problem types using the Take From context: result unknown, change unknown, and start unknown. Students need experience and practice with all three types.

Type: Problem-Solving Task

Tutorial

Exercising gorillas:

In this tutorial video from Khan Academy, a word problem is solved with unit cubes, as well as with a missing addend addition equation and a subtraction equation.

Type: Tutorial

Parent Resources

Vetted resources caregivers can use to help students learn the concepts and skills in this benchmark.

Problem-Solving Tasks

Finding a Chair:

These problems explicitly describe one-to-one correspondences without using comparison language. Such problems are easier for students to solve than problems that use comparison language such as "How many more?" or "How many fewer."

Type: Problem-Solving Task

Field Day Scarcity:

The purpose of this task is for students to relate addition and subtraction problems to money in a context that introduces the concept of scarcity. Scarcity occurs when you want or need more than you can have. Students may want to buy everything but will discover that it not possible with only $7 and they will have to make decisions.

Type: Problem-Solving Task

Boys and Girls, Variation 1:

Students may use either addition or subtraction to solve these types of word problems, with addition related to the action of putting together and subtraction related to the action of taking apart. Depending on how students think about these word problems, either is appropriate for the "addend unknown" problems. Seeing it both ways emphasizes the relationship between addition and subtraction.

Type: Problem-Solving Task

At the Park:

This task includes three different problem types using the "Add To" context with a discrete quantity.

Type: Problem-Solving Task

Maria’s Marbles:

Students benefit from encountering one problem type limited to small numbers and to develop strategies for that type of problem before encountering mixed sets of problems and larger numbers that distract the student from the problem itself. Over time they will be able to distinguish between types of problems in mixed sets and apply the appropriate strategy to solve each.

Type: Problem-Solving Task

The Pet Snake:

The purpose of this task is for students to gain a better understanding of measurements with the example being the growth of a pet snake.

Type: Problem-Solving Task

Sharing Markers:

These task types represent the Take From contexts for addition and subtraction. This task includes the three different problem types using the Take From context: result unknown, change unknown, and start unknown. Students need experience and practice with all three types.

Type: Problem-Solving Task

Tutorial

Exercising gorillas:

In this tutorial video from Khan Academy, a word problem is solved with unit cubes, as well as with a missing addend addition equation and a subtraction equation.

Type: Tutorial